The Effect of Imagined Brightness on Pupil Size: a Tool to Quantify Aphantasia?

By Claire Vanbuckhave, Nathalie Guyader, Léo Pasturel, Nicole Huson, Téo Pesci, Hélène Lœvenbruck, A. Chauvin
English

The aim of this study was to replicate previous findings that the pupillary light response (PLR) reflects the sensory strength of imagined brightness, and to investigate the sensitivity of such a measure. Fifty French participants without aphantasia perceived and imagined a series of bright or dark geometric shapes (oriented triangles) while their pupil size was recorded. Participants’ visual imagery abilities were assessed throughout the experiment (trial-by-trial vividness ratings) and with questionnaires (Questionnaire upon Mental Imagery; QMI). In contrast to previous findings, we did not replicate the effect of imagined brightness on pupil size and found no positive relationship with self-reported vividness on trial-by-trial ratings nor with mean questionnaire scores. These results challenge the use of pupillometry to sensitively detect aphantasia. Implications for future research are discussed in the light of current theories of aphantasia.

Go to the article on Cairn-int.info